One major reason why TLOU doesn't deserve it; GAMEPLAY. Its not horrible, but it clearly and afterthought. The stealth elements are quite possible the worst in video game history. Inexcusable lack of consistency in the design. Gunplay is also sloppy, but understandable given the material and characters.
In terms of the ''resonate'' sentence. Thats simply down to playstation fan presence on websites, fansites and blogs.
People have compared TLOU to MGS4 and I agree entirely on this. In a few years, people will look back on how bad the gameplay actually was and watch it disappear from the ''top 10 games'' lists.








