DerNebel on 10 November 2013
It kinda looks like there are scratch marks on the left stick doesn't it? Also I've looked abit through the Reddit thread and it seems like this controller was used by 4-6 people to exclusively play Fifa aka the game that has probably destroyed as many controllers as friendships. 
But well let's see what happens, generally I'd always blame people for not handling their stuff with enough care, but if something like this becomes widespread then that's an obvious sign that Sony cheaped out on the rubber.
