tired of the Live vs. PS+ debate!!

[Sevengen]

Nem said:

Sevengen said:

Nem. You started by telling me that I wasn't correct, Why? because "I was comparing the wrong things."

In a subsequent post, you told me I wasn't comparing them because I see them as different services.

That's a contradiction Nem, you contradicting yourself.. an inconsistency in your very own argument and your understanding of the OP.

Nothing about what I said was unclear, you simply didn't read it for what it was and now you just wanna keep posting in a vain, silly attempt to prove you did. Well, if that were the case then there'd be no ambiguity in your arguement and you wouldn't have changed what you believed i was saying, as you did in later replies. 

I can keep this going forever if you like. you're not going to get the last word. you were mistaken right outta the gate.. and you know that,  just refuse to admit it ...typical internet forum posturing. 

You wanna argue my point of view, my opinion, fine. do so... but at the very least, keep it respectful and understand that all this stuff is... is opinion. Don't start by telling me I'm wrong, disagree with me sure, don't tell me I'm wrong... tell me I'm comparing the wrong things and then later backtrack and say I'm not comparing them.  And for the love of god man, if someone catches you by your own words, stand up, admit it.

Ok, one final time cause im tired of you trying to drag this into something annoying and repetitive. You compared the wrong things. You cant compare PS+ and Xbox live and say they are different services when PS+ doesnt exist without PSN. You made a simple statement: PS+ is a renting service and Xbox live is a gaming service so they cant be compared. I set out to prove to you they are comparable. I am right. To specify even further, you say PS+ is a renting service, that is incorrect. Its a gaming service just like Xbox with a component or pack that includes renting of select digital goods. Its not even comparable to regular renting services because you cant choose what it is you are renting. PS+ is not a renting service, its a gaming service premium. So, yes, once more i say: you compared the wrong things.

End of the day, if you want to say reviewers arent comparing services the way you want, go on and say that. Dont try to be a smart guy and say they arent comparable, cause you might end up saying comething that isnt quite accurate. Oh and you can reply to this if you want. I dont care about the "final word" at all. I dont think there will be any further progress on this debate.

For what is worth, i agree with the point you were making about reviewers. Hope you can make a consistant post without any questionable claims next time so we can focus on the point at hand. :)

 so now your back to saying I compared the wrong things, after already saying I wasn't comparing them because I think they're different services, after already saying I was comparing the wrong things. 
Nem how can I be comparing them if I'm telling people they're different services and shouldn't be compared??
Answer that for me... how can I be comparing them if I'm telling people they're different services and shouldn't be compared??

look, my internet's paid, I get plenty of time off from work and I have every opportunity I need to keep jumping back to this forum and pointing out your mistake. You wanna keep posting, have at it. You accused me of comparing the wrong things when I'm obviously not, the point of the OP is that they're different services, PS+ and Xbox Live Gold, and shouldn't be compared directly. 
That's what the post says. period. read it a tenth time if necessary. 
So where's the comparison?
Show me.