IGN gives Brawl 9.5/10! Woot!

[Final-Fan]

Riot Of The Blood said:

naznatips said:

 

That's ridiculous. You don't compare graphics to other platforms. You compare them to the other games on the platform in question. Otherwise DS graphics would never score above a 3, and PS3 and 360 graphics would never score above an 8 after Crysis.

Ok, then here's my question:

If you're a reviewer and you're not really impressed with the graphics because you have seen better, do you give the game a high score in graphics anyways because of the system it's on? I don't think you should do that. It would be like giving the PS3's motion controls a high score just because they're ok for a PS3 game, though you know what motion controls can really do after playing the Wii's resident evil.

So you would agree, for instance, that graphics scores for DS games should be capped at 5, Wii at 8 or 8.5, and 360/PS3 at 9 or 9.5? Because that's the argument you're making.