GTA 5 impressions?

[Kantor]

dsage01 said:

Kantor said:

I love all three, but Infinite was more creative than The Last of Us and had better storytelling than GTA

Considering you prefer storytelling (judging by your post) over gameplay and replay value that's understandable.

All three have great storytelling and gameplay, but where gameplay is equal, I think storytelling helps to differentiate the GoTY from the other outstanding games that came out in a given year.

For what it's worth, I haven't really got much replay value out of Infinite or TLOU. I doubt I'll get any out of GTA, but it's already much longer than the other two combined, so that doesn't really matter for me. My most played game of the gen (Civilization V, about 140 hours) wouldn't crack my top ten, so as you say, I'll place a shorter and more memorable experience above a much-played favourite anytime.