Kantor on 04 July 2013
- Half-Life 2 is an overrated, dreary corridor shooter that is surpassed by even the most generic and lame of modern FPS.
- Demon's Souls' checkpointing is stupid and irritating.
- Dead Space is neither especially scary nor remotely enjoyable.
- Witcher 2 is seriously lacking in scope for a western RPG.
- Mass Effect has been an excellent series throughout, and ME3 was the best in the trilogy.
- TF2 is dull and repetitive, and only playable in short bursts.
- Earlier Civilization games are unplayable compared to Civ 5.
- Pretty much every game released during the 5th generation (and the first half of the 6th) is unplayable today. This includes many of the so-called "greatest games ever made": FF7, MGS, System Shock 2, Ocarina, Baldur's Gate and its sequel, KOTOR, the list goes on.
- Mirror's Edge is a stupid idea, and it's nauseating and doesn't flow at all.
And until recently I would have said "Bastion is extremely overrated" but I gave that another try, and it's actually brilliant. It just has one of the worst openings of any game ever.
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
