Full rankings, without EA since I didn't watch it:
4) Ubisoft - 2/10
Absolute catastrophe. Aisha Tyler was okay last year, but this year she was just pathetic and not at all funny. They showed garbage after garbage, and nothing new that looked remotely interesting. After the last two years' fantastic performance from them, this was extremely disappointing.
3) Nintendo - 6/10
This was a solid conference. They showed off plenty of new stuff in a fairly short space of time. But almost none of it really appealed to me personally.
2) Sony - 8/10
The price and used game announcements were bombshells and the atmosphere after them was fantastic. The few exclusives they did show look great, and the indie support is very promising. Plus, all of those multiplats (my god, there were a lot of multiplats) are running great on PS4, and they were fun to watch.
1) Microsoft - 9/10
No television, no movies, no gimmicks, no dull kinect minigame collections. Just great-looking game after great-looking game. A real pleasure to watch. But their silence on their DRM policy was deafening, and that price is pretty prohibitive. Neither of those things really affected my perception of the conference though.
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
