Nintendo Franchise Tier List (New Poll for Zelda tier)

[Otakumegane]

SlyFoxDeveraux said:

Star Fox is too low. Most games in the series have sold over a million. Yes, the most recent two haven't, but both were portable and one was a remake. A new core entry into the franchise is really guaranteed to make over a million, assuming Wii U's established enough. I'm not sure I don't think it should B-tier, but it should CERTAINLY be C-tier.

Also, Zelda I do think should be A-Tier. Just looking at Skyward Sword is folly, Wii was a dying console that no one was playing by that point. Just as Wind Waker on a new console sold more than Majora's Mask on an old one, Zelda's first Wii U game will do much better than Skyward Sword.

I'm going to need a stronger argument for Starfox. The OoT3D remake sold 3 million. Starfox3D is at .7 million, and both those games are a remake of the best selling games of that series. 

 

As for Zelda, yeah it's looking to go into A-tier.