Nintendo Franchise Tier List (New Poll for Zelda tier)

[Otakumegane]

Cold-Flipper said:

Otakumegane said:

Cold-Flipper said:

I would put Animal Crossing in S-Tier

New Leaf will definitely hit 10 Million IMO.

I spilit the Pokemon franchises as they are spin-offs rather than part of a main series.

AC however, can't really be seperated into a Console and Handheld franchise. Will be placed in S-tier if NA numbers for AC to rise.

Why just if NA sales rise? If it sells 10 Million WW it is S-Tier according to your OP. You based it off potential too, AC has a ton IMO. Judging from your sig, you don't see it. I'm assuming that's why it's A-Tier.

Now remember that the AC franchise originally got it's start on consoles. I can't rank it at S-tier based on handheld series alone. To do that I would have to spilt up the franchise into 2, the handheld and console componets, which I can't really do because they all play the same. It makes sense that the console Pokemons (Stadium, XD) are different from their handheld equivalents.

Animal crossing though isn't really something that can be divided into 2 just because they exist on 2 kinds of systems. It would be like dividing up the 2D marios on both handheld and console. So for now considering that the handheld is S and the console is B I took the one in the middle which is A. It's the best I can do for now.

(I mean come on spiltting up Pokemon and Mario makes sense due to all the spin-off series and what not. Animal Crossing should stay as 1 franchise.)