Nintendo Franchise Tier List (New Poll for Zelda tier)

[Otakumegane]

Immortal said:

Otakumegane said:

I'll Keep SSB at S, the sales increased over time even with a smaller userbase from N64 to GC.

I will move Zelda down to B for now. I might fix it up if the HD zelda is looking to do strongly.

Animal Crossing only is S-tier on handhelds only, and I'm actually not quite sure if EU and NA can drive it up to S. Leaving it at A.

Fair enough for AC. The 3DS is already demonstrating that unreal success in Japan doesn't necessitate any success at all elsewhere so it's fine if you're doubtful.

I still disagree on SSB, though. At this point, it's completely unreasonable to expect the next SSB to sell 10m+; the WiiU userbase is just too small and it's completely untested on handhelds. Given that you're ranking these by current sales potential, putting it that high seems unrealistic.

Plus, I don't see why you're so stubborn about splitting Mario. ;P The subfranchises have completely different sales potential so ranking them together makes no sense.

I am splitting mario, a lot of people seem to want it.