All hope for Sony and Microsoft is lost

[kingofwale]

Gamerace said:

kingofwale said:
>@kingofwale - Virtually any casual girl game will be given poor reviews from a large portion of game critics.

since people here are so willing to compare this game to DDR, Guitar Hero and Rockband games, last time I check, those "casual" games didn't get poor reviews at all.

did casual girl game like Nintendogs get poor review? I don't think so.

If this game is truly innovative like some of you believe it would, why not wager and take the risk a little. ;)

Nintendogs, like typical Nintendo, is very polished.

GameRankings score for Cooking Mama - 66.8%.

Is CM a game with terrific quality? No. Is it fun and sells terrifically to girl gamers? Yes.

At best this game will be Cooking Mama comparable. At worse it'll be, as you guys say, crap for the naive. But since Namco isn't known for making a lot of crap cash-ins - and feel free to educate me if I'm wrong on that - then I think we should at least keep an open mind about it.

 you are already deemed this game as 'unpolished'?

 and since we are on CM, the game is far from just 'unpolished', it didn't get 66 for having only 1 flaws. I shall save my time here and not name the next 9 reason why CM is only a 'passable' game.

and oh, you are giving way too much credit to Namco. If this game is made by Nintendo, then it's a different story, you'd expect Wiiplay quality at least.