Is Pokemon going a generation too far?

[SecondWar]

JayWood2010 said:
By the way I disagree with this article. I think pokemon still looks fine and the gameplay is amazing and addicting. Easily my favorite JRPG games and some of my favorite games of all time. In fact Black/White has been my favorite since Crystal so I actually think they are improving.

I cant wait for X/Y

Same here, article is flawed (second gen has 100 new Pokemon, not 150. Only Gen 1 and Gen V has 150 or more). Also last sentence:

Is Pokemon going a generation too far, or is it completely appropriate for another generation to arise?

What is the difference between the two options? IGN is clearly out of touch.