on the 360 controller, i love that the left one is on top because that's much more natural so i prefer offset on this controller. if i have nothing in my hands my left thumb has almost the same position so yeah, very natural to me.
but it could be also symmetrical as long as the right stick would be on top because on the right side, i already have to move my thumb all the time to change between buttons and sticks so i think that wouldn't make any difference.
wii u pro controller could be also great for me as symmetrical controller because of the left thumb on top (as long as i don't need the d-pad that is much better in my opinion)
so yeah, i don't really like how they managed it on playstation controller but not because of symmetrical or offset, because of the position of the left stick.
but the bigger problem for me are other things with this controller, position of the sticks is only a small part and the ps3 controller is the reason why i play all multi-plat games on xbox.
