1) Your quote trees are getting obscenely large. No more than three, for the sake of all of our sanities.
2) Stop bickering about this and just drop it. It is honestly no concern of any of yours whether or not he owned a 360. Feel free to discard his opinion and consider him a liar if you don't think he did.
As for the topic, it really depends. It would be in addition to the PS4 rather than as a replacement, just because of all of the Sony franchises that I love. So probably later in the generation when it's a little bit cheaper and has a good number of exclusives to differentiate it.
It's certainly too early now when we know practically nothing about the system.
Oh, and if it uses Kinect as a primary/sole control system, that's an instant "no" from me.
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
