The Last of Us for me.
I am a huge God of War fan (all three of the main series games are in my top 50) but it's starting to get stale. They've really done everything they can do with Kratos and now they're just milking him for all he's worth and refusing to bring in a new character and setting like the series needs.
Beyond looks great from what we've seen, but what we've seen isn't much. And Quantic Dream is pretty hit and miss for me: I love Heavy Rain, but I'm not really a fan of Indigo Prophecy.
Last of Us, on the other hand: Naughty Dog has been consistently excellent for the last 15 years. I love Uncharted, and it clearly takes some inspiration there. The characters are deep, the setting is interesting, the AI is actually intelligent. I see nothing at all to dislike, and a great deal to love.
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
