Well this seems to have become the AC3 discussion thread, so:
-Connor is wooden and I don't like him at all.
-Do you support the revolutionaries or are you just using them? Make up your damned mind already.
-On the other hand, I have a newfound respect for Shaun, and William seems like a nice guy, if a little too intense.
-Achilles is great.
-Haytham was cool. I miss Haytham.
-The combat is largely the same as before, except even simpler, because apparently it wasn't easy enough already.
-Why can't I grab ledges when I'm falling?
-I do like how it's more difficult to use firearms now with the long reload times.
-Boston is completely empty. Seriously. Florence, Venice, Rome and Constantinople all had shops on every street corner. Tailors, blacksmiths, doctors. Boston has like three general stores and nothing else.
-Climbing now involves no skill at all since everything is automated. Climbing trees is really cool, though, and running between them is even better,
-Mail delivery is the worst filler I have ever seen.
-Recruiting assassins actually requires some effort now. Nice.
-Horses are back!
-I love the naval missions and Fort Wolcott especially. The other forts are pretty lame because you can just run in and gung-ho the entire thing.
Better than AC1, better than Revelations, not as good as AC2 or Brotherhood. On the whole, I'm a little bit disappointed, and it's about an 8.5 for me so far.
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
