NSMB2 is an exceptional game in the eyes of reviewers

[amp316]

RolStoppable said:

pezus said:

To be fair, neither NSMB DS nor Wii got a 90+ metascore either. And this is the third one, we'll see how it goes for Galaxy 3.

There have been plenty of games in the seventh generation that went into round 3 or even beyond and didn't get panned for it.

Have you played GTA 4?  It's the greatest game of all time.  The reviewers said so and I always trust the reviewers.