By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
rocketpig said:


Okay, I have to ask. Outside of the visuals, what makes Sin City so great? Its schlocky dialogue? The gratuitous T&A? The corny acting? Once you get past the stunning visuals, the movie is incredibly mediocre. I enjoy the movie and have watched it a half dozen times but as an overall movie, The Avengers is a better film. The Watchmen was okay. Spider-Man 2 was decent.

Outside of TDK, all the movies you listed are somewhere between mediocre and good, not great.

There is nothing quite like Sin City's atmosphere,there was absolutely no boring moment for me.The violence displayed in the movie was both brutal and entertaining at the same time.Overall,I just love the storyline,and the movie stays very true to it's original material.

In my eyes,it's a timeless classic,because it shows the dark side of humanity in a very entertaining,but disturbing way.

Saying that Sin City is mediocre places you in the minority,since it's highly rated between both critics and audiences.