Why wouldn't you play with good looking characters ?
Maybe not the metrosexual acting ones *cough* Hope *cough*, but other than that most characters are fine.
Points I agree with are #2, because I enjoy watching movies in games I really like but can't be bothered watching them in a mediocre game. Long dialogues are always boring though no matter the game's quality.
#4 because I feel like missing out if I can't use them, but mostly I'm not interested enough to play through the whole story again just to use the other characters.
and partly #9.







