Kantor on 31 October 2011
...are you serious?
The enormously critically acclaimed sequel to game of the year with an enormous advertising budget and incredible production values on what is now a highly successful console with an install base of over 50 million, releasing during the holiday season, or a launch title of questionable quality on an unproven platform launching in March?
Uncharted 3 by a huge margin.
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
