The Uncharted 3 OVER Battlefield 3(X360) CLUB!!! Update 12 sept.

[sales2099]

CGI-Quality said:

sales2099 said:

Also Theres ratchet and clank Tools of destruction vs Crack in Time.......also lower 

lbp2 is tracking lower trhen part 1......all spin aside. Notice ALL my examples had more then 1 release on the PS3. 

GOW3 previous release is on PS2. When GOW4 comes out id be happy to bet that ps3 gamers wont care as much. GT5 previous release is on PS2....thus also not a proper counter. When GT6 comes out (IF.....and thats a big IF) on PS3.....id also wager it would sell less. Heavy Rain is a new IP.....no sequel on ps3. Nice try. 

Killzone 3 and Infamous 2 are also tracking below their predessors. Slightly......but you'd expect the sales or sequels to rise.....not be on par/lower.

This isnt a 360 discussion. I simply made a point with evidence for all to see that PS3 exclusive sequels sell less then the predessor PS3 release. Its not like im offending you directly......im merely pointing out a fact. 

So now the argument changes. First you say "PS3 fans don't care about the exclusives anymore" and now it's "they don't care about sequels". Interesting. Killzone 3 is actually tracking ahead of Killzone 2 in the same time frame, & Uncharted 2 already outsold Uncharted 1. inFAMOUS 2 just came out a few months ago and is tracking right with it's predecessor (which in fact, could go on to outsell it). All complimentary examples.

Outside of the semantics, your comment was baseless. Plain and simple. I only used the 360 as an example (whether the discussion is about it or not) because in that context, it made sense. It could only have struck a nerve if there's some truth to it. For instance, Fable III didn't outsell Fable II. Crackdown II sold less than it's predecessor. Does that mean people care less for 360 exclusives? What's good for the goose is good for the gander. Remember that.

Never did.....my examples were all exclusives with a previous release on PS3. They are still exclusives but clearly you saw me ONLY referring to sequels under performing to a previous PS3 release. 

I just checked the 10 week totals of KZ2 and KZ3.....3 is tracking below. Infamous 2 is tracking slightly below part 1 in the same 9 week timeframe. But again....its not encouraging to see sequel sales tracking slightly lower when they should be higher if these exclusives are truly "worth buying". Nice try. 

And thanks for confirming my origional sentiment that Uncharted 2 was the sole exception. All though Uncharted 3 might just track lower, well see. 

I matched you point for point here. Sequel exclusives just underwhelm in sales. 

And your right, 360 users dont care about non Halo/Gears/Forza exclusives. But that was a given. The truth that ps3 gamers dont care about their exclusives (with ps3 sequels) is still a cleverly concealed truth.