RATE Harry Potter & The Deathly Hallows Part 2! (The final film in The Potter Saga!!)

[lestatdark]

dsage01 said:

lestatdark said:

darthdevidem01 said:

...

Great film but nowhere near as good as other saga finale's like Return Of The King, Return Of The Jedi, Revenge Of The Sith etc

Now Darth, I know you're a big new trilogy fan, but Revenge of the Sith doesn't deserve to be on that list. It didn't improve on the weaknesses of the entire new trilogy and added a few more, especially given how they pratically destroyed the conception that the old trilogy created of Darth Vader with the fight in Mustafar. 

RotS is probably the best of the three new trilogy movies (although my personal favourite is Phantom Menace, mainly because of the best fight scene in every star wars movie with one of the best songs as well, Duel of the Fates and the Pod Race), but it's miles away from the quality of Return of the Jedi and Return of the King. 

Also, how would you rate Alan Rickman's performance?

I'm sorry Revenege of the sith is by far the most epic movie I have ever seen. I rate Harry Potter a 9/10 because it was simply amazing and Daniel Radicliifs and Alan's Rickman's performance was just stunning

Revenge of the Sith did have some pretty good epic set-pieces like the battle with Grievous, Order 66 in Kashyyyk, the destruction of the Jedi Temple and Anakin's moment of turning to the dark side.

My main grievance with RotS is that the build up of the character of Darth Vader in the movie didn't match up a lot with both the old trilogy and how they were portraying it in the new trilogy. They completely cast aside the whole "the one to bring balance to the force" profecy, the high chancellor/emperor Palpatine interactions were poor, given that Palpatine was supposedly leading him on the dark path (that wasn't well conveyed in the RotS, they did a better, much subtler job on Attack of the Clones) and the scene were Anakin snaps at Padme could have been done much better.