By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Torillian on 25 June 2011
Edit Thread
Final-Fan said:

I have to say I disagree in principle.  If you're judging it by today's standard in the score, shouldn't it also get a chance to compete against today's games for GOTY?  On the other hand, you could just say "well we decided to give the other games a chance and not get destroyed, so we excluded this" but that's more out of pity than principle. 

Frankly if a game released 13 years ago can still be GOTY in 2011, I want to see that shit go up on the scoreboard!  Proof once and for all that Nintendo games are timeless! 

P.S.  I admit there's also the practical challenge of finding judges you can count on to not have rose colored glasses, but also not be biased against it. 


hmm...actually hadn't considered the fairness between the review style and the GotY awards.  I suppose yer right that if you compare it to the current gaming industry for the review it should be up for GotY awards as well.  I don't think it'll win any personally (other than 3DS specific awards) but it should be in contention.  



...