EMEAA up!

[Michael-5]

CGI-Quality said:

Michael-5 said:

The data for GT4? Your on VGChartz! Go look up the worldwide weekly sales yourself!

When a court is in session, who's job is it to find/present evidence to a claim? The Defense Attorney's job is to defend the claim. The Prosecution (the side making the claim) is responsible for evidence.

In other words, I didn't make the claim about GT4, you did sir. Therefore, as in a court case, absent evidence means one of two things - you can't provide it or it doesn't exist.

I could have tackled the rest of that post, but it truly is you, again, thinking somebody is looking to insult you. There are things you said though that can be debated, such as: "being in the top 10 for over a month is hard, only a few games ever do this. However these are the games with strong legs, that sell 10 million or more units. Halo, Call of Duty, older GT's, GTA's they all do it, but GT5 doesn't". One of several problems there - you are, again, making claims with nothing solid. Show me past GTs that were in the Top 10 for 24 weeks, or much longer than GT5. How do you know GT5 won't have strong legs? All claims that are mere speculation, all, nothing more. 

As for being rude, you seem to have a hard time dealing with being called out, or being asked to back up your words. You have been inconsistent in some areas here, but instead of getting so defensive each time I quote you, you could reasonably address it, as I have with you.

Being called out is different from name calling. You can questions someones opinion without insult. You don't seem to understand the difference, and I can't explain it any better over texts.

As for GT4 staying in the top 10. Your on VGCharts. Look up worldwide weekly sales between February 26th, and August 13th 2005. You will see August 13th is the first week the game dropped out of the top 10, and up until May the game held within the top 3 positions, only to come second when a new game launched. GT4 was released August 22nd 2005 in Americas.

None of this court stuff, your not a kid, the tabs are right at the top of your screen, and your on the website which holds the facts.

My claim is solid, are you now calling VGC data false? Please, just stop hassling me, I'm asking you politly.

It's my opinion GT5 won't have stong legs. For all we know Polyphony may decide to massivly bundle the game like they did GT3 in the west. If that happens then for sure this game will break 10 million, and I will be wrong, at least on total sum. Opinion, speculation, is there really a difference? Is anyone here 100% right on future sales predictions? If they were, why aren't they professional analysts? Stop hassling me just because I disagree with you, and can back myself up. You can't always win you know.