By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
jarrod on 15 January 2011
Edit Thread
Doobie_wop said:
jarrod said:
Doobie_wop said:

Most of the HD plat-forming base are on their online networks. Limbo, Joe Danger, S'plosionman, P.B. Winterbottom, Blade Kitten, Trine, Braid, Raskulls, Shadow Complex, Super Meat Boy (probably the best of it's genre), Quest for Booty and heaps more are available to download between the two platforms. They may not get the same sales compared to the  mega games like the five or so Mario games that makes up the Wii's number, but the plat-forming genre is alive and well online and the releases have been pretty consistent and frequent. 

Also, as someone else mentioned earlier, comparing the best selling genre from one platform to another can only end badly when people start coming in with FPS console comparisons, RPG console comparisons, Hack 'n' Slash console comparisons and so on.

Wii also has FAR more platformers on Virtual Console / WiiWare than they do retail.  Super Mario Bros. on VC has likely outsold every XBLA or PSN platformer by itself.

I'm guessing that Super Mario Bros. has probably been emulated  on Android phones more often than the total PSN/XBLA platforming sales combined, it doesn't take away from my point that the HD on line services have been very consistent with quality and frequent platfromers. The OP said that the genre was dead on the HD consoles, I argued that it's alive and well, but it's limited to the online services. Hell, a few of the Game of the Year attendees from 2010 were Joe Danger, P.B. Winterbottom and Limbo (sources mainly include Weekend Confirmed, Giant Bomb and Joystiq). 

Just because one thing does better than another, it doesn't make the other thing a failure.

Alive? I'd definitely agree.  Well?  I'm more conflicted on that one.

I'd say the entire genre being restricted to almost only downloadables on the HD twins isn't the picture of genre health I'd like.  I love XBLA/indies, but it really is a second class market (and more like third world for poor Indies)... it's basically saying the genre isn't worth "full" value/release on HD, it's budgetware.

People have made the comparison to Wii RPGs or FPS in this thread, but at least Wii can still support those genres with full priced, full scale retail releases.  I haven't really seen that on the HD twins from a 3rd party since Sonic Unleashed two years ago...