Kennyheart said:
Kantor said:
Khuutra said:
Kantor said:
You're entitled to your opinion, of course.
But 0/10? Really?
All of the battles? The clone army advancing to fight the droids? Yoda fighting Dooku? Obi-Wan fighting Jango Fett? Mace Windu?
Surely, even if this doesn't redeem the movie, it does keep it from being a total catastrophe in the eyes of even the harshest critic, surely?
Same message to Twesterm, except that he didn't pretend to justify it.
|
You start talking about battles and we're going to start talking about Hoth or the Death Star Trench.
Nobody wants that.
|
Obviously, nothing on Hoth or the Death Star Trench, but they're from the original trilogy, all of which are brilliant movies with fantastic writing, engaging plots, brilliant acting, and epic battles (despite being designed with 1970s technology).
I'm not saying Geonosis is anywhere near the AT-ATs on Hoth, or Luke destroying the Death Star, or even the final battle on Endor, but it was a good fight scene, and I would put Yoda vs. Dooku as the second best lightsaber battle in the prequels (After, of course, Anakin vs. Obi-Wan).
|
That fight was really pointess.The point of that figth was that obiwan crippes anakin.It did not have to be that long of a fight and been in those conditions.It could have last 35 seconds and accoplished more than the orignal fight did.
|
The prequels stand up almost entirely on well-designed fight scenes with good cinematography. Yes, the fight scene could have been 35 seconds. It would also have sucked and not have been the best part of Episode 3.
But that's a discussion for the next thread.
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
