"Valkyria's probably embarrassingly overtracked for the Americas. A (questionable) NPD placed it's US ltd around 150k last fall... VGC tends to do this with core niche games for some reason, it also happened with Demon's Souls"
that's you saying that Demon's Souls is "embarrassingly overtracked" in NA. Is that what you would call the differences we're seeing?
If we ever have shipping figures from Sega similar to these we'll know for sure for Valkyria Chronicles but until that point the argument is pointless since you're basing it off an entirely unsubstantiated source that we can't just trust at face value saying a figure from another tracking source that can have issues with tracking just like VGC does (not as often but it definitely is still possible since they are estimates)
...
