By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
ZechsMerquise said:
jarrod said:
ZechsMerquise said:
jarrod said:

Nintendo's own lineup is fine, great even... the problem (as ever) is with 3rd parties.

Also, DQX will be the "last Wii hit", not Zelda SS. :P

This year has seen some great third party games - Red Steel 2, Monster Hunter Tri, Tatsunoko vs. Capcom have all been great. There's still Goldeneye, COD:BO and Sonic Colours still to come.

Great games sure, but outside MH3 and Sonic Colors, they're all still "B team" efforts.  That's still fundamentally the 3rd party problem on Wii, they almost always bring the B/C tier efforts and cry foul when it doesn't merit AAA sales....

Agreed - to a degree! I get a little tired of hearing about how badly third parties perform on Wii. There have been a lot of BIG third party games that also flop on the HD consoles, but for some reason people don;t enjoy talking about that, what's more when an HD game flops it has a lot more to lose. Just look at the underperformance of Lost Planet 2 or the poor openings of Castlevania and Enslaved.

 There has a been a lot of third party success on Wii, it just hasn't been for more traditional games. But the problem isn't just with the Wii. Great games like Bayonetta fail to do a million on either system, but games like Medal of Honor (which to by all accounts is lack lustre to say the least) sell well.


That's because, in addition to what you wrote, failures and success are a lot more complex than the one-dimensional notions many hold about what games sell on what system. MoH has a strong pedigree, even if the series has had a slide from grace this gen. Bayonetta is from a studio loved more by the vocal gaming community right now than general gamers. Thus neither it nor Madworld had the brand names to open large. Perhaps further games will sell better as gamers know the studio more, but it will be uphill until they get a strong franchise.



A flashy-first game is awesome when it comes out. A great-first game is awesome forever.

Plus, just for the hell of it: Kelly Brook at the 2008 BAFTAs