To be honest, it kind of depends on what system you play the game. If you play it on PC both point one and six(auto-aim and poor physics) become obsolete. And because of the better shooting point two isn't true aswell, i actually find the PC version to easy. Also Mafia II actually runs decently on a average pc, oppossed to the terrible port that's called GTAIV.
Also Mafia II has a few advantages over GTAIV aswell, like a better atmosphere and story.(although this has more to do with taste).







