In retrospect, I think we're all being a little harsh on Sony. We all had very strong preconceptions (I wrote a feature about them!) and we were disappointed when our "predictions", because that's what they were, didn't ring true.
I mean, some parts were just plain bad. The Coke deal (why do we care? Ah well, at least they threw KB in afterwards), Tiger Woods 11 (pretty much identical to the Wii version) and Medal of Honor, which ended up looking like a complete clone of MW2, with a slightly different font used for pop-up text. And this, altogether, took up.... ten minutes?
Aside from those, can you really think of anything which shouldn't have been there? An awful lot which could have been there, but that's what the leaks of the last month were for. Then, Tretton rambled a little, but he's actually a good speaker. Not as adorable as Iwata, of course, but a lot easier to understand, and Don Mattrick is completely devoid of charisma.
I'll still say Nintendo was in first place, but Sony wasn't actually that far off.
9/10 for Nintendo, 8/10 for Sony, 5/10 for Microsoft.
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
