By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Rpruett on 05 June 2010
Edit Thread
dtewi said:

MARCUSDJACKSON said:

look. im not debatting this. so what she makes no sence. if it in 3D already you can say shes out of her mind. but her right ti an opinion right or senceless as it maybe is hers


You're missing the point.

Everyone has a right to an opinion, but the basis on which said opinion is set can be incorrect and false.

Do you understand?

THAT ON WHICH AN OPINION IS SET IS ALLOWED TO BE ARGUED AND IN TURN MAKES THE VALIDITY OF THE OPINION COME INTO QUESTION.

Again:

MORGAN WEBB DOES NOT LIKE SUPER MARIO GALAXY 2. SHE SETS THIS OPINION ON THE IDEA THAT THE GAME IS NOT 3D ENOUGH AND IT IS TOO CARTOONY. THESE REASONS ARE NOT VALID AND WE CAN QUESTION HER OPINION.

Again:

EVERYONE HAS A RIGHT TO AN OPINION, BUT THEY ARE ALLOWED TO BE CHALLENGE IF THEY ARE UNREASONABLE AND HAVE NO SOLID REASONS TO BACK THEM UP.

Again;

JUST BECAUSE YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO AN OPINION DOES NOT MEAN IT IS NOT ALLOWED TO BE QUESTIONED.

Do you understand now?


The word 'Cartoony' can be a very subjective word.  It can be very open-ended.  Her definition of Cartoony and your definition of Cartoony may very well differ.  Essentially making your 'opinion' that her 'opinion' has no ground to stand on....and invalid one.    So while you can certainly question it, debate it, argue it.   You cannot act as if it is unreasonable, illogical, or even has bad reasons for having it.

If the game is 98% 3D (Your words not mine) than what about that 2%?  Is she not allowed to really dislike that 2% that isn't 3D?    Again, you are saying her opinion is crazy, absurd, has no basis to be made because it stands in directly opposite to yours.

 

In otherwords, You can't say her opinion on this matter is incorrect or false because you cannot prove it. And they aren't horrible reasons. Mario is a cartoony game.  Some people will love that (And have), some people will hate that (and have).  Super Mario Galaxy 2 has 2D parts (True or false?)  That might be too much 2D for someone.  (Again which would validate her dislike for it.).

 

I think Nintendo fans upset by this need to get over it.  She doesn't like the game.  That doesn't mean she has some weird bias against Nintendo or anything absurd like that.  It means she is disappointed for a myriad of reasons with the Mario series.   I actually agree with that notion as well.