Can't Believe myself... I bought Red Dead over ModNation...

[ZenfoldorVGI]

CGI-Quality said:

Seece said:

CGI-Quality said:
@ Zen

I wonder this, since I see you defend it so often, how would feel if said that Half-Life 2 was crap, even though they haven't played it? You'd be in here slinging punches like a beer belly in a drunk fight.

Keep that in mind while you're speaking about what MNR should/shouldn't cost, or how there are "better" games out there.

He's not saying MNR is crap.

He makes a valid point, you could apply your "choice" method to everything in this world. There comes a point where a bar needs to be put in place though ...

Making a valid point doesn't excuse everything else he's posted in here. He said there are better games out there and that it isn't worth $59.99. Both are bold and uncalled for, particularly when he's basing some of that on reviews (which aren't bad to begin with) and not personal playtime.

It's hard to come up with a object outlook when you have no experience to have any outlook in the first place. And of all people, he should know this, he gets on  people for their "out of place" judgments all the time.

Valid point....and no, I'm not saying MNR is crap(I've said time and time again, that I haven't played it, and don't know its quality). I'm giving my opinion that based off of no play time with the game, and from what I've heard, the game is not worth 10 dollars more than RDR from my gut feeling.

For me, the game doesn't feel like a full retail release, due to a few things, like lack of hype despite being a PS3 exclusive, and par reviews, demo impressions, loading times, actual nature of the game compared to competition, and pricing compared to competition(it's actually more costly than the vast majority of new games on Amazon, at the full 59.99 price tag) ect. I wish it was 39.99. Plus, there is already a fantastic imo AAA game in that genre on the console for around 20 bucks called Wipeout HD, which is one of my favorite games this generation.

Now, hell yes, I would be upset if some troll came in with a one liner talking about how much Galaxy sucks compared to LBP or the like, but if someone was honest, and openly admitted their opinion, I might not like it and yes I might oppose it, but it is their right, and the reason there is even a forum to begin with.

I think more people would agree with me about MNR, than you would expect. Imagine if the game wasn't a PS3 exclusive. Imaging if it was a multiplatform game, selling for 59.99 which required a patch to be playable, and imagine it was launching against RDR and Alan Wake. How many people would object to me opining that the game should be discounted then?