Red Dead: Redemption (Review Thread)

[Carl]

coolbeans said:

Carl2291 said:
I just KNEW this would rate well.

Everything about it seems awesome. It's like what GTA4 SHOULD have been!

Seems like it.  I mean everybody knows there's horseys in NYC too!  That missing detail really hurt IV in my mind :P.

Horses > Cars!

Revolvers > Deagle's

Hunting > Going to the bowling with an annoying cousin!