Barozi on 19 March 2010
All 3 games deserved it.
People are just angry, because CoD4 was already a masterpiece and Infinity Ward only improved some parts of it and didn't completely redesign it.
And personally I don't see what Uncharted 2 did so special than other AAA games.
My personal vote would go to Assassin's Creed 2, with Modern Warfare 2 as a close 2nd and Uncharted 2 as 3rd (out of these 3)
