PS3 will never catch the the 360 now. Wii won a long time ago.

[Final-Fan]

jarrod said:

Final-Fan said:

jarrod said:
And no, Natal's not been overwhelmingly received, and there's lots of questions and behind the scenes skepticism.  But even at this early stage with no formal games announced, it's still had a far more positive response than Move.  The hype's on Microsoft's side, it has been since last E3 even, and it's really "their game to lose" among the HD motion interfaces.

From a very casual perspective (meaning not too much attention paid to either side of the new motion controls), I've heard the main criticism of Move is "it's a total ripoff of the Wii, possibly inferior", while the main criticism of Natal is "it'll never work and if it does no one will want to develop for it". 

Both are damning, but Natal's criticism is much more concerning from a practical standpoint.  IMO.  If I've heard the mutterings correctly. 

Core criticisms aren't core response though.  The mainstream media's approached Natal as "new" and imaginative, while they've cast Move as "redundant" and an imitation. Natal's most definitely gotten a more positive response at this point, and we still know next to nothing about it compared to Move. :/

Of course the lack of information could be part of it, Microsoft's selling Natal to the media a lot on faith and their stagecraft is unrivaled (both Sony and Nintendo could learn some lessons there).

That may be, but hype and buzz won't save a product. 
IF the criticisms of Move are true, then Sony is guilty of shamelessly copying Nintendo (again) and the PS3 can expect a lot of crappy Wii ports. 
IF the criticisms of Natal are true, then it will either limp off the market (after a strong start due to hype) or just be a very niche product. 

Which one has worse consequences for the success/failure of the motion control system in question?