By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Torillian on 04 January 2010
Edit Thread
PorkChopTD said:
Torillian said:
PorkChopTD said:
Xen said:
Did it ever occur to you that HD games may be better then their Wii competitors and that is why Wii games don't take GOTY? (Besides, last year, the Wii got nothing worthy of the title).

A simple as it is to respond to your post.  Let me start with this.  Will you ever play MW2, Uncharted 2 (blah blee freaking blah) again after MW3, Uncharted 3 come out?  The answer to that is NOPE!

This^^^ is why games like Punch Out, Super Mario Brothers, Metroid, Zelda ect are better games.  The replay value is unlimited and will never go away.  I still like to play NES game from 1985.  Will you ever freaking play the original Gran Tourismo again? NOPE! once again.  HD Games are in no shape or form better than games like Little King Story or NSMB Wii. 

Wow the game looks great!  Oh, but it is the same as every other freaking game with a different story line.  This is where XBOX360 and PS3 are making mistakes.  They need more games like Little Big Planet to compete.  Guess what they don't want to, they want to focus on graphics.  I don't care how good it looks, if I can't figure out the 70 buttons to push

 

 

So the fact that you love NES games means that all Nintendo games should win every GotY forever?  This is one of those "Nintendo makes classics and noone else does" arguments that makes me want to hurt Nintendo fans.  The fact that I won't play Uncharted 2 after Uncharted 3 comes out is inconsequential and an assumption on your part that isn't true.  The GotY is supposed to go wo the BEST game of the year, not "game most likely to be a classic" like this is some video game high school yearbook.

I sorry you just proved me right!  A classic game is like the hall of fame for sports.  My idea of GOTY is based on pure fun and replay value.  That is what the Wii gives.  Super Mario Bros games are like.  Jack Nicholas is to Golf - Joe Montana is to Football - Pele is to Soccer - Micheal Jordan is to Basketball need I go on?

NSMB Wii is plain and simple a better game to more people live with it!

I'm fine with the fact that more poeple like NSMBW, I mean they'd have to since more people have played it.  But what do you base that purchase off of?  you don't play the game and then make your purchase decision.  GotY is supposed to be based on a group who plays as many of the best games as possible and makes a decision on which one they played was best.  This means that it isn't based on sales, and it isn't based on what game's publisher rhymes with Wintendo. 



...