Most Legendary Video Game Character?

[Carl]

Snake - 22
Toad - 16
Gordon Freeman - 2
Cloud - 2
Mario - 4
Sonic the Hedgehog - 1
Link - 1
Prince - 1
Guybrush Threepwood - 1
Madison Paige - 1
Ms. Pac-Man - 1
Reverend Ray - 1
Kratos - 1
Exploding Barrel - 1
Gran Turismo Driver Guy - 1
Kirby - 1
Pikachu - 1
Pitfall Harry - 1

Toad gaining 2 votes per vote is unfair, and unkind!