This fanboy chatter is all just a pseudo competition.
Does the NBA give the championship to the team that was most profitable?
Does the GOTY poll factor in how much profit the developer made from the game?
It's pretty irrelevant how much money a company makes.
As has been said before, each company has a different holistic goal. Nintendo is the only company that HAS to make money from it's gaming division because that's all it is, a gaming company. On the other hand both MS and Sony also use their gaming division as a supporting role to it's other divisions as well as the potential to make money from it. Sometimes the gaming division has to suffer financial losses to help out the company wide goal (i.e. Sony implementing Blu-ray, MS cutting prices to increase marketshare).
Edit: Oh yeah when the hell did VGchartz get Polls??
