Pachter : I'm TROUBLED by Lackluster Uncharted 2 SALES!

[darthdevidem01]

steverhcp02 said:

darthdevidem01 said:

 

1. Yes then I am crazy

I do not see uncharted 2 having legs like Uncharted 1 throughout the whole of next year, thats the crux of my argument, that is why I don't see it hitting 3 Million.

Uncharted 1 was a new IP & a hit

Uncharted 2 won't have legs like it after the holidays are over

@CGI

it sold 113K in November

it sold 227K according to VGChartz

I do not think OVER HALF of its sales came from outside North America...so yes its overtracked even after including mexico & Canada

Do you always just use whicheever data set meets your argument? Or do you have a history of always using NPD for your predictions?

I use both sets of data

 

@pezus

yes why doesn't that make sense?

I predicted 2 - 2.5 Million, I believe it will top around 2.6 Million

I am closer than people who predicted 3 - 4 Million

as LTD sales are out no-one can be sure of who was closer yet

& I am not claiming VGChartz is wrong & NPD is right, but in the software department I would go with NPD