I don't understand how Shattered Memories can get low scores.

[MaxwellGT2000]

bmmb1 said:
Gamespot review up, gave it an 8/10.

"This brilliant reimagining of the spooky series' progenitor is a breath of fresh air that will stick with you despite its shortcomings.
The Good:
# Deeply emotional story with great pacing
# Incredibly haunting atmosphere
# Your experience depends on how it profiles you.
The Bad:
* Far too short
* Puzzles and nightmares are always the same."

And here's what they said about the shadows :

"Shattered Memories is very dark and moody, and from its impressive use of lighting and shadows to the creepy, real-time freezing effects of the nightmares, the titular town on display is at its finest..."

Funny how the good points on this is night and day to GameInformers uh... words on a page (not dignifying it by calling it a "review")