Resident Evil 4 vs Uncharted 2: Which game is better for their time?

[Kantor]

CGI-Quality said:

Kantor said:

CGI-Quality said:

Garnett said:

RE4 was a game that was HUGE! Im talking HUGE! Uncharted 2 is just a good game.

Well, to be fair, Uncharted 2 is much more than just a "good game'. It is huge too, particularly because of when it hit, right after a price cut and system revision. However, it isn't a game changer quite like RE:4 was in the previous gen.

Game changer? RE4 did nothing for the GameCube, and actually sold more as a late port on PS2.

Anyway, just to be a rebel, I'll say Uncharted 2.

I wasn't talking about sales. It sold more on the PS2 for obvious reasons but was not received as well as the Gamecube version. It also has, so far, paved the way for future titles (Gears of War, Dead Space). Uncharted 2, as of now, hasn't done that yet for obvious reasons.

Everything isn't always about sales.

Ah, game changer in that sense.

RE4 was not the first TPS, not by a LONG way. Certainly not the first TPS with cover, either.