Our Top 100 NES games

[masschamber]

Kenryoku_Maxis said:

atma998 said:
@kenryoku_maxis

I know you're a DQ fan. Which DW do you think is the best between III and IV? I personnaly think it's DW4 do you agree?

Definitely hard to say.  Since they're both so different from each other.  Personally, from the NES versions, DQIV had better fine tuning of the overall Dragon Quest system, balance of gameplay and scope.  However, once their remakes were made, I think they're both equally great games.

So for the NES, I'd have to say Dragon Quest/Warrior IV is best.  But with the remakes, they're both equal.

masschamber said:

Kenryoku_Maxis said:

masschamber said:
This is the "official" list

'The list'

I'm not going to go into the list like you wanted us to before, but I just think you should go back and play all those games, then make a 'list'.  I usually don't say this, but I don't see how you could make half those choices after playing the games.

Which I have played more than 3/4 that list and own half those games.

believe me, I've played them,all of them, I play ever game I buy (through junk stores, garage sales, flea markets, etc I've accumulated over 600 different nes games so I've played some obscure titles) for some time and everyone of those game I have played extensively because I like them,  the list is based on my opinions, which are going to be different than everyone elses, that is why it is a starting point, frankly I wouldn't be surprised if half or more of the list is different in the end

please give me your opinion on the best nes games, tell me how to modify the list, make it truely representative

also as atma said, which dragon warrior is better 3 or 4?

anyway atma your right, I'll pm a couple of the guys that are big on the nes and hopefully get some valuable input, though I haven't seen simon belmont or commando post in forever

Personally, my top 10 NES games would be:

1. The Legend of Zelda

2. Kirby's Adventure

3. Dragon Warrior IV

4. Dragon Warrior III

5. Super Mario Bros 3

6. Castlevania III

7. Dragon Warrior

8. Super Mario Bros/Duck Hunt

9. Ninja Gaiden

10. Duck Tales 2

But this is just my personal list and I didn't want to impose this on yours.  It was just that a lot of those games on your list seemed like filler.  If those are the top 100 of the ones you've played, then sorry for thinking of them as such.

your opinion is exactly what I am looking for, I want to create a list that is fairly representative of the community.  My opinion was just a starting point it was never meant to be final

@atma I thought I fixed I'll drop the games that were meant to be dropped