Uncharted 2 - the highest rated game ever?

[Kantor]

GameRakings is better for comparisons, since it uses decimals.

http://www.gamerankings.com/browse.html

Currently the 9th highest score of all time, counting GTA4 PS3 and 360 as the same game. It used to be 5th, though, so you never know. It will stay on the first page of that (which I believe is the top 50) for sure, though.