What makes a good Action RPG?

[Carl]

Crashdown77 said:

Carl2291 said:
Baldur's Gate 2

If you count it as an ARPG, it demolishes all ARPGs released this gen. And last gen. And the gen before.

The only real competition it has is Diablo, and going by reviews... Baldur's Gate 2 > Diablo.

This would be true in a world without KoToR.

How the hell did i forget about KoToR? o.0

Okay, KoToR is also in competition with Baldur's 2... But by reviews, Baldur's 2 > KoToR also

*Hands in Gamer's license for forgetting about Knights!*