PS3 Best Games Guide.

[Kantor]

Bobo012893 said:

Great thread. I think that you should rank games by their metacritic score as opposed to their VGchartz score.

I think that by ranking the games by their metacritic score you incorporate views from a much larger variety of reviewers and avoid the potential for ubalanced or biased reviews.

Ex.

Valkyria Chronicles>Fallout 3

Although I love Valkyria chronicles, ranking it above games such as Fallout 3 and Oblivion is kind of rediculous.

In order for it to be a TRUE PS3 best games guide I think this change is necessary.

I disagree. This is VGChartz, and since we have reviews, we may as well use them. Metacritic sucks for ranking, because it incorporates all kinds of crappy reviews from random no-name reviewers, and that can bring the score down significantly. And if you ask around on this site, the overwhelming majority of members will prefer VC to both of those games.