Project natal PS3 killer? or 360 killer?

[Kantor]

damndl0ser said:

Kantor said:

pterodactyl said:

Definitely a PS3 killer. It'll bring the casual crowd towards the 360 and make them see the PS wand as nothing but a cheap knockoff.

Do you mean the casual crowd as in the crowd who already own 360s (many casuals do- they consider themselves hardcore but they're not), or the "casuals" that the Wii appeals to? If the latter, you're setting yourself up for massive disappointment. Because they're too busy playing their Wiis.

If Microsoft were to launch Natal next generation, that might make a significant difference. If it was bundled with the console. And thus completely ruined it. You do need buttons and D-pads and analog sticks for some experiences, and Nintendo remembered that even when designing motion control. To be honest, there isn't a lot you can do with "voice recognition" and...for lack of a better description, waving your arms and hands about. Certainly, it would work in some games, like the 3D breakout that was demoed, or maybe some mini-games. But let's have a look.

SHOOTER: Okay, how would this work? Perhaps you point your finger to shoot. Okay. How do you move? Reload? Change weapon? Jump? Take cover? Crouch? Roll? (unless you're planning to do a forward roll into your TV).

FIGHTER: We've all seen the cute little ad from E3 with the guy doing a ninja kick against the kung fu master. Seriously? Do you really think people are going to punch and kick and slide like in Tekken or Soulcalibur? And what about special moves?

RACING: We saw this to a certain extent with Burnout Paradise on...was it Jimmy Kimmel? (celebrity endorsement, of course). He steered very accurately. He was also going extremely slowly. How would he boost? Brake? E-brake? Change to rear view? Reverse? Change gears?

In fact, I'd like to know which games currently available on 360 could possibly work with Natal, and failing that, an idea of a good, deep game, that would work solely with Natal.

The best case scenario I can see for Natal is it becoming a secondary mechanic, like Sixaxis. You are playing Gears of War 3, you select your grenade, raise your arm, and throw. It can't be used as a sole control method like a gamepad, Wiimote+Nunchuk or, now that I think about it, a PS Motion (depending on what the PSMotion ends up looking like).

To summarise that relatively long post, Natal doesn't really have that many practical uses in gaming.

I think your looking at the Natal and Sony's wand in the wrong light.  They don't have to be geared toward every game made.   I am 99% CERTAIN microsoft isn't stupid enough to leave out an actual controller pad in their next console or in the new Natal 360.  Nintendo has an entire lineup of games that work well with its motion sensing and this has completely taken it to Sony and Microsoft this gen.  To simply write off its success or appeal to people is ludicrus. 

 

If Natal works properly and there are a few good titles when it launches, it will be huge.  I can see microsoft completely ripping off Nintendo's entire lineup and making it work better.  Just like they did for windows.

I understand that, and if Microsoft releases their NATAL 360 with no controller, they are doomed to failure. The problem is, while I can think of uses for the PS Motion (since it's basically a Wii Motion Plus but more accurate and with a coloured orb!), I can't think of many for Natal. There's the usual EyeToy stuff, and EyePet, but really, what can NATAL do that the PS Eye can't? That isn't a rhetorical question, I really do want to know.