Most overated game of all time.

[Barozi]

Hmmm the only 3 I can think of are GTA4 (still AAA though) and LBP. Killzone 2 is also a tad overrated.

 

EDIT: Didn't read puffy's post.

The whole Zelda series (mainly the 3D games) is overrated. I personally wouldn't give them a higher score than a 8.5 max.