Just finished inFamous...Which one did you choose?

[Kantor]

inFamous first, and I could tell the game was designed around it (duh, judging by the name). The powers were better for Evil Cole, the story had better consequences, and Arc Lightning >>>>> Overload Burst. The only real advantage of being good was that citizens would throw stones at enemies instead of you. I was disappointed by how little the story changed, and I think if you want a good Karma system, you really need to differentiate the story as well as the gameplay.