scribblenauts has rickroll

[Torillian]

Paul said:

Torillian said:

MaxwellGT2000 said:
Ok within context of what was actually said, the game will get boring after 10 minutes and the execution was bad.

These guys that have voted on it have actually played it, done so for longer then just ten minutes, and the fact that they comment over and over about how much fun it is to solve one level in different ways is proof of concept.

Seriously how can you argue with that?

Sure, I can argue that. 

The issue with the concept is that all the random people you can call upon just wave their arms at each other until one of them dies. 

What's the difference between pitting God and Cthulu against each other instead of Isaac Newton versus Giant Squid?  In the end they will wave at each other until one or both of them die, and that is how this game could get boring after the initial fun of just seeing if they actually acounted for every word ever.

I'm fairly sure the game involves solving some 200 puzzles using your imagination. The 2 different entities waving their arms at each other isn't the main point of the game to my knowledge.

Which is a worthwhile argument for why it won't get boring in 10 minutes, unless you have an amazing puzzle solving rate.  But what people saw at E3 and based their awards on I could easily see getting boring for some.