There are plenty of crappy reviewers who are on my "ignore" list: GameSpot, Edge, Variety, Teletext Gamecentral, Gamestyle...actually about half the sites that Metacritic uses.
I am indifferent towards GamePro, though I'll admit that is one of the worst reviews I have ever seen. Its fail level is up there with GameSpot's Tools of Destruction review, if not higher. But, one strike is okay. The best of reviewers trip up sometimes (Resistance 2 9.5? Seriously?).